Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Book Review: "Twilight Girls"

Twilight GirlsTwilight Girls by Paula Christian

My rating: 3 of 5 stars


Two lesbian pulp novels from the vaults. The first one, "Edge Of Twilight", is surprisingly good; the best such novel I have read, having gotten started with Ann Bannon's "Odd Girl Out" which I found by accident in a used book store. In the 1950s and early 60's, there were no lesbian presses turning out books for gay women to enjoy; these paperback novels with their lurid covers were it. In "Edge", airline stewardess (they weren't "flight attendants" yet!) Val McGregor has a cool job, her own apartment, and male pilots wanting to paw her luggage. But Val feels like something is missing, and that something turns out to be another stewardess, the very fetching Toni Molina. The first story bucks the norm of the time, which was that the women in these novels could get a taste of honey, but then had to commit suicide, go mad, or end up in ruins. In fact, it has a sweet happy ending, much to my overjoyed astonishment when I read it.

But then it's as if the powers that be must have insisted the author atone for that by writing a sequel in which everything goes to hell in a handbasket. In "The Other Side Of Love", Toni inexplicably has morphed into a psycho stalker, Val moves back home where she can get terrible advice, and just to make the destruction of the first story complete, she goes to a (male) headshrinker and receives the most unintentionally hilarious bad advice ever. Val even mulls this stuff over and decides he may be right! The ridiculousness of all of this is tempered by the knowledge that this scenario actually played out far too many times back in the bad old days. Skip the second story, unless you just want to read it as historical dark comedy.



View all my reviews

5 comments:

Daryl said...

thanks for the reviews ... now go write a great lesbian novel .. you know you've got the talent

Helen said...

Daryl is SO right!

On another note/genre, have you read "Gone Girl?" I just finished, giving it 4.9 out of 5.0!!

hedgewitch said...

A sad commentary on how social pressure warps artistic execution. (You'll note there's a similar theme with all anti-establishment females--as John Steward so famously said about Jenny in Forrest Gump, "She was a hippie, so she had to die.") But at least you got the first story, which is a good thing.

And I also second most strongly Daryl's suggestion.

Mama Zen said...

Twilight Girls contains the novels "Edge of Twilight" and "The Other Side of Love." I point this out just in case anyone else is as easily confused as I am!

This makes me wonder . . . were lesbians the intended audience for the lesbian fiction of the time? The whole heroines coming to tragic ends as punishment for their "sexual deviance" seems like such an odd message to be throwing at the consumer you're trying to sell to.

HermanTurnip said...

I'd have a higher opinion of the Twilight movies if this book was a spinoff.

Alas, Twilight still sucks.